Thanksgiving menu

Our Thanksgiving Orders are now open!

Thanksgiving orders can be placed over the phone or in person, and payment must be made upon ordering. All orders must be placed by Saturday, November 23rd for pickup on Tuesday, November 26th or Wednesday, November 27th.

This year’s Thanksgiving menu, along with our holiday hours, is available for viewing HERE.

Happy Thanksgiving!

Celebrations Menu

Our Celebrations Menu is designed to help you make your meeting, party or special occasion the best it can be. We offer a wide range of bakery items including cookies, pies, cakes and pastries, as well as breakfast trays, quiches and coffee.Let us design and make your perfect cake for your special day, we also offer wedding cake to order!

Sourcing local foods is a core mission of Elm Street Bakery and as the seasons change - so does our menu.  

Please note that all celebration orders must be placed and paid in full at least 2 days before pick-up.

You may also click to download the Celebrations Menu below: 

Please utilize the below form to send us your order request:

Name *
Name
Phone *
Phone
Desired date for pick up *
Desired date for pick up
Desired time for pick up *
Desired time for pick up
BREAKFAST
Assorted Mini Bakery Tray | $32
Serves 8-10 people. A variety of our most popular breakfast pastries including cranberry orange scones, banana bread, ham & cheese croissant, apple cake, blueberry muffins & gluten-free pumpkin.
Quiche | $24
Serves 6-8. Choose from two options:
Apple Cake | $22
Serves 10-12.
Lemon Loaf Mini Bundt Cake | $ 10
Serves 6.
Pecan-Sour Cream Coffee Cake | $15
Serves 6-8.
Banana Bread | $14
Serves 8-10.
Gluten-free Pumpkin Bread | $15
Serves 8-10.
Bialys with Cream Cheese | $18
Half-dozen. Choose from the following options:
Cinnamon Rolls | $20
Set of 6 - *Saturdays only*
Coffee | $18
Serves 6-8. Roasted and brewed on-site.
COOKIES
Cookies | $22
By the dozen. Serves 8-10.
Chocolate-dipped Coconut Macaroons | $30
By the dozen. Serves 8-10.
Decorated Sugar Cut-outs | $30
By the dozen. Serves 8-10. *Custom designs available - pricing based upon request.
Assorted Mini Cookie Platter
Choose from two options:
PIES
Our pies change seasonally - please call for current options.
9-inch Streusel-topped Pies or Single-crust Pie | $22
Serves 6-8.
9-inch Double-crust or Lattice-pie | $24
Serves 8-10.
5-inch individual pies | $66
By the dozen.
DESSERTS
Vanilla Bean Cheescake | $42
Serves 10-12.
Mini Vanilla Bean Cheesecake | $66
By the dozen.
Flourless Chocolate Souffle Cake | $38
Gluten-free. Serves 8-10.
Chocolate Tart | $38
Serves 10-12.
Chocolate Carmel Tart | $38
Serves 10-12.
French Apple Tart | $38
Serves 10-12.
Chocolate Almond Ganache Cake | $38
Serves 8-10. Gluten-free.
Lemon Meringue Tart | $38
Serves 10-12.
4-inch Mini Tarts | $66
By the dozen. Choose from the following options:
ROLLS
Rolls | $9.50
*Minimum roll order is three dozen. Choose from the following options:
CAKES
6-inch Round | $22
Serves 6-8. Choose BOTH cake type and buttercream frosting choice from below:
9-inch Round | $32
Serves 10-12. Choose BOTH cake type and buttercream frosting choice from below:
12-18 inch Half Sheet | $75
Serves 40-50. Double-layered, filled cake. Choose BOTH cake type and buttercream frosting choice from below:
Cupcakes | $32
By the Dozen. Choose BOTH cake type and buttercream frosting choice from below:
Please fill out the below form with further details or other inquiries on any order item(s) from above or reach us at 716-652-4720. Thank You!