Place pre-orders for Buffalo Bills Cupcakes from our takeout section today!
Elm Street Bakery is currently hiring for a part-time Dishwasher-daytime and evening availability is a MUST! Apply on our "work with us" tab!
*Online orders placed between 8-11 am may be picked up at the Bakery Counter, from 11 am-close in our Market*

Fresh · Local · Seasonal

Elm Street Bakery began from a desire to create a community gathering place where neighbors could break bread over fresh, seasonal food sourced from local farmers in a warm and welcoming environment.

The General Riley Speakeasy is Open!

The General Riley Speakeasy is now open,
hours are as follows:

Thursday - Saturday
4pm - 10pm

To Rent the speakeasy for a private event in the future, call 716-652-4720 for availability & Pricing

The Speakeasy is a casual environment to enjoy a great cocktail, beer, or glass of wine with friends & family.

The General Riley Speakeasy is located behind Elm Street Bakery, inside the General Riley House. Look for the gas light to be flickering, welcoming you in.

We hope to see you soon!

Order Takeout

Please use the link below to view and
select from our available offerings.

Online ordering:
orderonlinemenu.com/
elmstreetbakery

Our curbside pick-up has moved inside to our Market area,
please come inside and let us know you have arrived!


You can be assured that our staff are following CDC guidelines for your health and safety.
We look forward to serving you!

Order Online

The 'BREADULE'

Our breads are made the traditional way, using the
simplest and most wholesome of ingredients.
Hand-shaped and baked in our wood-fired brick oven,
each loaf is truly a work-of-art baked every morning.

TUESDAY

EA Sourdough
Sunflower Levain
Caraway Rye
Honey Wheat
French Batard
Sesame Batard
English Muffin
Baguette
Focaccia

WEDNESDAY

EA Sourdough
3-Seed Sourdough
French Batard
Sesame Batard
Baguette
Country White
Caraway Rye
Brioche
English Muffin
Focaccia

THURSDAY

EA Sourdough
Grain Up
Pain Rustique
Caraway Rye
French Batard
Sesame Batard
Baguette
Honey Wheat
English Muffin
Focaccia
Volkornbrot

FRIDAY

EA Sourdough
Sunflower Levain
French Batard
Sesame Batard
Sesame Semolina
Farmer Ground Organic Whole Wheat
Baguette
Country White
Caraway Rye
English Muffin
Focaccia

SATURDAY

EA Sourdough
3 Seed Sourdough
Caraway Rye
Cinnamon Raisin
Honey Wheat
Ciabatta
French Batard
Sesame Batard
Seedless Rye
Farmer Ground Everything Sourdough
English Muffin
Baguette
Focaccia

Introducing Two Tree Beer available
exclusively at Elm Street Bakery

We are proud to present Two Tree Beers, an easy drinking summer beer.
Available daily in-store or in our Summer Hut. Enjoy it today!

The day begins with the arrival
of the bread bakers...

...they begin by sweeping the ash from last night’s fire, mopping the oven and taking their dough that has been happily fermenting in bannetons (French proofing baskets) out of the proofer to be baked in our steam-injected ovens or signature Alan Scott wood-fired masonry oven. The pastry chefs are the next to arrive and after grabbing a coffee they prepare to bake off our morning breakfast offering: blueberry and coffee cake muffins, banana breads, lemon loaves, and cranberry and bacon scones are just a few of the things making their morning appearance. However, the pièce de résistance is our daily French pastries or viennoiseries like croissants and pain au chocolat.

As dawn breaks, freshly-roasted coffee that we roast in our German Probat roaster and sizzling bacon for our breakfast sandwiches combine with the smell of freshly-baked sourdough bread, bialy’s, wood-fired English muffins, and pastries. These scents create a magical way to start the day...

Read More

We are proud to reflect our agricultural community through our belief in serving food that is fresh, wholesome, local, and seasonal.

Farms across our region supply us with fresh dairy, meat, produce & artisan products.

Elm Street Bakery is Hiring!

We are currently looking to fill multiple positions on our team!
-Dishwasher: daytime and evening shifts
To apply, please follow the link below to submit your resume, cover letter & contact information to our General Manager.

Celebrations Menu

Click the button below to view our celebrations offering.
All orders must be made 72 hours in advance to allow our pastry department ample time to craft your desired order.

To place a request for a celebrations order
please call 716-652-4720 or visit us in-store.

View Offerings